Your domain registration is pending. Check back in an hour


Calling all brides to be….

Call the shop for you reservation to an after hours free tastings and dessert tastings. Case items will be available for purchase. (717)462-6687. Spots are limited

Call now

We have a new item on the menu. Come try our cheesecake stuffed strawberry French toast or the Oreo French toast stacker if you dare (three pieces)! Also available in a single or two slices! Order delivery or take oujt as well! Delivery and Call Ahead:

Call now

Todays Case Options! Stop in and grab your self something yummy or the whole office! Feel free to call ahead with your selections, pay by phone for a quick and easy pick up

Call now

Remember we open at 11 today so you can do your purchasing before Santa comes 12-3. Case is stocked and we will be making coffees!


2 days ago
We are so happy with our decision in choosing Nothing Sweeter for our wedding cake & cupcakes. We ordered about 180 cupcakes for guests and a small wedding cake (just for the bride and groom). We were able to mix-and-match cake flavors and icing to choose exactly what we liked. We loved that we could customize our options (ex: we wanted only 20 of one cupcake but 60 of another). They even included an anniversary cake, which is so much better than eating cake stored in the freezer for a year! On the wedding day, they delivered the items by working with the venue coordinator and everything turned out perfectly. The cupcakes were gorgeous and everything was delicious. Our ONE suggestion is if you don’t have a wedding coordinator, stay organized in payments or pay all-at-once in the beginning. About a week prior to our wedding, we wanted to check-in with all our vendors. We realized before calling that we were about 4 days off in our payments to Nothing Sweeter, and technically in our ...
- Nina K
a week ago
Nothing Sweeter did an absolutely amazing job for our wedding cake and cupcake dessert table! Their free cake tasting made the process simple and allowed us to customize our wedding cake to the needs of our taste buds. They had free range to decorate the table and we were floored by the results! Our dessert and cake table for our wedding was beautiful and tasty! I couldn't have asked for anything better.
- Allison W
5 months ago
Great selection of rotating baked goods available in their cases. Our family enjoyed getting breakfast here because there were both sweet pastries and savory options. The crab quiche was like eating a crab cake in a quiche. Soooo good! The kids gave it 10/5 stars, but that's not an option here.
- Lindsay d

Custom Cakes, Pastries, and Desserts

Our products are made fresh and with the best ingredients possible. We love what we do and you will get the best customer service care that you deserve. Every cake is different and every order is different so for you to get the best possible pricing please call so we can discuss all the details. Thank you for choosing Nothing Sweeter to be part of your special day!

Cake Ordering Process: When it comes to ordering a cake, a lot is involved. We bake all cakes fresh to order, fillings are made in small batches based off what amount is needed, and decorations are handmade or ordered when needed. This fresh and specialized process is what makes us stand out from the grocery stores and competitors. We would appreciate at least one week notice for all cakes, desserts, or pastries.  If an order requires fondant, special ingredients, or decoration that needs ordered we need a minimum of two weeks. We juggle caterings, birthdays, anniversaries, weddings, company celebrations, bar mitzvah’s, Quinceanera, sweet sixteen’s and more. The best way to order is to come in to the shop in person or call us during our normal business hours. We will gladly walk you through the process of covering all the required specifications for your event. 

Contact Us


Call now
  • (717) 462-6687


Get directions
40 Noble Boulevard Suite 20
Carlisle, PA 17013

Business Hours

Tue:7:00 AM – 4:00 PM
Wed:7:00 AM – 4:00 PM
Thu:7:00 AM – 4:00 PM
Fri:7:00 AM – 7:00 PM
Sat:7:00 AM – 4:00 PM
Contact Us
Message sent. We'll get back to you soon.